The long awaited Right to Information, RTI, rating is now published. Australia is positioned in the middle, while pillar systems of FOI/RTI, such as Sweden, Norway and Iceland, are on the lower third of the rating. Have a look at Peter Timmins excellent summary in his Open and Shut blog.
I’m on the international advisory panel for the rating and have pointed out before and will do so again that the rating instrument is incomplete until a practical information access component/measure has been incorporated into the methodology. This was always the intention, but funding such a global study will be costly and it was decided to start with an assessment of the laws.
As a legal comparative study the RTI rating is the most ambitious FOI/RTI assessment tool thus far. But the current rating is incomplete in that it favours new laws over old ones. In terms of practical access the current rating puts Serbia at the top and the ‘template systems’ of the US and Sweden in the middle and on the lower half respectively. We know from earlier studies (Lidberg FOI Index, 2009) that practical information access is a problem in newer FOI systems and that old laws at times deliver far better practical access than the new ones. This data needs to be captured and worked into the RTI rating.
It will be very interesting to correlate the Australian RTI rating with the data I capture on the practical information access when I assess all Australian FOI systems starting next year – 2012.
My take on the prosecution of Witness K
Fear is a tricky thing. It’s often hard to distinguish between what is real and … Continue reading My take on the prosecution of Witness K
ABC caves in after political pressure – latest piece in the conversation
The ABC’s chief economics correspondent, Emma Alberici, did her job the other day. She wrote … Continue reading ABC caves in after political pressure – latest piece in the conversation
Australia – world champ in anti-terror and security laws
My latest piece in The Conversation on the proposed federal bill on foreign interference and … Continue reading Australia – world champ in anti-terror and security laws
‘In the name of security – secrecy, surveillance and journalism’
Our book assessing the impact of anti-terror, secrecy and surveillance laws on in-depth public interest … Continue reading ‘In the name of security – secrecy, surveillance and journalism’
How should research into journalism be assessed in Australia?
In the July edition, 2017, of the Australian Journalism Review one section of the journal … Continue reading How should research into journalism be assessed in Australia?
The Senate inquiry: How governments can support public interest journalism
Drawing on the Journalism Education Research Association Australia’s submission (that I contributed to) I outline … Continue reading The Senate inquiry: How governments can support public interest journalism
‘A government without newspapers’ – why we should care about the cuts at Fairfax
Market based journalism is failing public interest journalism. It’s time for governments to consider how … Continue reading ‘A government without newspapers’ – why we should care about the cuts at Fairfax
Trump supporters playing with nationalistic fire
Has nationalism combined with xenophobia ever brought the world anything good? The answer is no. … Continue reading Trump supporters playing with nationalistic fire
Journalism in the era of post-truth and fake news
Confidence in the media has long been low, but can we really afford a society … Continue reading Journalism in the era of post-truth and fake news
New article – Suspect identified: revisiting naming practices in crime coverage
Australian Journalism Review – Vol 38 Issue 1 (Jul 2016) with Steve Lillebuen and Philip … Continue reading New article – Suspect identified: revisiting naming practices in crime coverage
New article: Information access evolution: assessing Freedom of Information reforms in Australia
Australian Journalism Review – Vol 38 Issue 1 (Jul 2016) The past seven years have … Continue reading New article: Information access evolution: assessing Freedom of Information reforms in Australia
Secrecy, Naru and Manus island
My take on our right to know what is done in our name in the … Continue reading Secrecy, Naru and Manus island